Now I wonder how different the Force Rc stuff is
https://www.horizonhobby.com/product/1-10-outbreak-4wd-monster-truck-rtr-black/FCES03001T2.html
I'm trying to remember the guys name that has the short course truck, he broke the chassis on his Warhawk and can't find one the Ecx and Himoto chassis are different lengths. Comparing the manuals the Force Rc is closer to the Himoto than the Ecx is.
I tend to agree. Things like the hinge pins being a U shaped assembly make me think closer to Himoto. In the Force RC manual, the axle in question is FCESS232006, which looks a lot like the universal shaped one you linked. I can find two, which use the same stock pictures 33604 and 33204. No details period on 33604, 33204 is listed as 105mm. 105mm what? Total length? total dogbone length? dogbone length eye to eye? The other thing I've been trying to do is reverse-search those amazon axles I have - finding all the other listings for them, seeing what model they claim they fit, then looking up that model's manual and parts diagram (hoping to find an alternate part number, or if I find that axle find the bearing they are using with it, or different outer cup, or anything really). Each and every time, I find the manual showing the model using a double-end dogbone with a differential output cup and a spindle axle cup, no CVD or universal on either end. So are these sellers just listing this mass produced China axle and hoping people don't return it? There is zero way it fits some of them - manuals like from Redcat are really detailed in their parts diagram and parts list/descriptions they say dogbones 61mm overall length 55mm pin to pin...the Amazon ones are 90mm pin to pin...why are they listed as fitting that Redcat?!?!
the rediculous priced ECX ones are still available, but leaves me with the problem of I now have one spare and no solution after that. there is also a bulk lot with a set of axles in it for $165 plus the shipping. I suppose having something made is always a money-is-no-object way of winning, but leaves me again with no solution past fixing it this one time. if I reverse-engineer to a dual sided dogbone, that actually allows me a lot more flexibility but there is a reason CVD/universal are an optional upgrade on brands. I've been unable to find just the dogbone (the shaft) in the right size thinking I would just swap over my wheel/spindle ends. benchtop lathe? mill down the amazon axles inner hub bearing area to 10mm to work? I really want a 3d printer and a lathe, but that will probably land me and James in BIG trouble.
I began trying to find (through generic 1/10 4wd cvd search) an option which would allow me to run a universal both on the transmission side and the wheel side and a slip joint in the middle (like we do on our 2wd Ruckus), but the problem is that on our 2wd and most 2wd, the differential outputs are a "male" which the axle then uses a set screw with. on this truck and lots of others, the differential output is a cupped "female." so, I need to figure out what models out there are relatively still parts available so I can start looking through their manuals to try and swap the differential outputs (probably including the spider gears), the entire diff guts, or the entire diff and housing.
If anyone wants to contribute to this list of manuals I need to look up and explore, please do. Criteria: 1/10 electric 4WD, SCT or MT type size/style, relatively parts available in USA, hobbyist (why companies like HB Racing is left out, largely a full race company). I did not repeat different models within the same company because they largely interchange parts (example: Slash and Stampede). Bonus points if you know the model has external male differential drives (to save manual looking).
Traxxas Slash 4WD ultimate
https://traxxas.com/products/models/electric/slash-4x4-ultimate?t=support
- uses male differential outdrives
- swapping entire diff may be a problem as diff bearings are 10x15x4 and 8x16x5 (ECX are both 10x15x4)
- front diff housing looks reasonably close and is available as a preassembled unit, has provisions to mount lower contol arms and front shock tower
Aarma 1/10 Granite 4WD
https://www.astramodel.cz/en/eview/ara102666-granite-3s-blx/chassis.html
- uses a crazy parallel planetary gear setup like an automatic transmission
- ring gear built into diff housing, splined male outdrives
- everything proprietary nothing worth exploring
Team Associated Rival MT10
https://www.manualslib.com/manual/1852575/Associated-Electrics-Rival-Mt10.html?page=10#manual
- uses male differential outdrives
- entire diff assembly looks much closer to ECX including 4 planetary gear setup, similar sun gear shim, o rings for outdrives, 4 bolt main gear, diff gasket, 10x15x4 bearings. Ring gear is 37T versus ECX 39T
- swapping housing would be a whole front end swap, diff casing very involved with mount points
- 25810 diff rebuild kit looks IDENTICAL to ECX internals except sun gears 14T versus ECX 20T (and diff drives, obviously). 25807 gets all 3 diff cases - look close with slight differences
Redcat Blackout XTE Pro -
https://dealer.redcatracing.com/manuals/BLACKOUTXTEMANUAL.pdf
- almost all Redcat products use cup/female differential outdrives
Team Losi Racing TEN SCTE-3.0 Race -
https://www.tlracing.com/ProdInfo/Files/TLR03008-Manual-MULTI.pdf
- almost all Losi products use cup/female differential outdrive
- LOSB3569 you'd be hard pressed to convince me that's not identical to the ECX diff internals
- housing uses 12x18x4 end bearings, ring and pinion cut very different (helical)
edit: updated list with notes. elminated a lot of candidates from list due to parts availability or other factors (example: Axial makes almost exclusively crawler with solid axle setups, not applicable for our IFS application). ordered some Traxxas and Losi parts to compare in person.